Closed Schools Are Creating More Trauma For Students

Apr 20, 2020
Originally published on April 21, 2020 5:20 am

The high school senior sitting across from Franciene Sabens was in tears over the abrupt amputation of her social life and turmoil at home. Because of the coronavirus, there will be no prom, no traditional send-off or ceremony for the graduates of Carbondale Community High School in Carbondale, Ill. And Sabens, one of the school's counselors, could not give the girl the one thing Sabens' gut told her the teen needed most.

"I want to hug them all, but I really wanted to hug that one," Sabens remembers.

Instead of a desk between counselor and student, there were miles of Internet cable and a computer screen. No hug. No private office. This is Sabens' new normal.

"Zoom is just not gonna ever bridge that gap," she says. "That one was pretty rough."

The job of the school counselor has evolved over the years, from academic guide to something deeper: the adult in a school tasked with fostering students' social and emotional growth, a mental health first responder and a confidant for kids, especially teens, who often need a closed door and a sympathetic ear. But the closure of nearly all U.S. schools has forced counselors like Sabens to reimagine how they can do their jobs. And the stakes have never been higher.

Why students need counselors now more than ever

Between closed schools, social isolation, food scarcity and parental unemployment, the coronavirus pandemic has so destabilized kids' support systems that the result, counselors say, is genuinely traumatic.

Sarah Kirk, an elementary school counselor in Tulsa, Okla., is especially worried about her students who were already at-risk, whose families "really struggle day to day in their homes with how they're going to pay the next bill and how they're going to get food on the table. Being home for this extended period of time is definitely a trauma for them."

For so many children, Kirk says, "school is their safe place. They look forward to coming. They don't want to leave when the day is over. And to take that away from them, I do worry about the traumatic experience that will cause for many of our students."

Counselors say part of the trauma comes from students being isolated from each other.

"In a middle school, that social piece is so important," says Laura Ross, a middle school counselor in Lawrenceville, Ga. Yes, they do a lot of connecting via social media, and that's still happening, "but that face-to-face and being with their friends... they're missing that."

Students are also experiencing a kind of grief "over what they've lost," Sabens says, especially seniors. "Losing out on the end of their senior years — something that they've dreamed about their whole life... has really been overwhelming for them. So there have been a lot of tears. There have been a lot of questions... 'What did we ever do to deserve this?'"

It's OK to not be OK. I mean, most of the world is not OK right now... It's OK to grieve about what you're losing because it is tragic. - Franciene Sabens, high school counselor

Unfortunately, there are no easy answers. Instead, Sabens says, she tries to let students know "that it's OK to not be OK. I mean, most of the world is not OK right now... It's OK to grieve about what you're losing because it is tragic."

Brian Coleman, a high school counselor in Chicago, says trauma is nothing new to many of his students, but he hopes awareness of the potentially traumatic effects of school closures means "trauma-informed care is going to really, really explode in ideally healthy, meaningful ways."

That means school leaders should right now be planning for the future, asking how they can best support students when they come back to school, Ross says, "making sure that we're prepared to deal with some of those feelings that are going to increase — of anxiousness, of grief, of that disconnect that they had for so long."

Broken connections

Not only are many students grieving and struggling with new trauma, it's also harder now for school counselors to help them. That's because counselors have lost one of the most powerful tools they had before schools closed: access. Before, counselors could speak to entire classrooms about bullying and how to manage their feelings, plus they enjoyed office space where students could drop in for a quick visit or schedule a tough conversation.

"I think about my eighth graders," says Laura Ross in Lawrenceville. "My office is in their hallway. I mean, they just stop by to say hello. They stop by when they're upset, just to come in and talk and, you know, figure out their feelings."

But all of that has changed. Today, a face-to-face video meeting is the closest a counselor can get to the old ideal. Before that can happen, though, Sabens says she has to find her students.

"Email, email, email, email — lots of emails," she says, calling it her "primary mode of communication with the students."

Connecting is even more complicated for elementary school counselors whose students generally don't have cell phones or email addresses. In Tulsa, Sarah Kirk says this inability to speak directly with children is "exactly what keeps me up at night."

So far, Kirk has mostly been in contact with parents and caregivers. "That's whose [phone] number I have... But it's really up to the parent if they want to hand the phone over [to the student]." She worries that, if a child is not OK at home and needs help, she won't know.

Kirk's focus on these calls has also shifted away from academics toward "the basic needs of our kids... making sure they have enough food. We're making sure they're safe."

Evelyn Ramirez, a first-year middle school counselor in rural Redwood Valley, Calif., agrees: "Our main priority right now is just to check the welfare of each student."

Ramirez, a first-generation Mexican-American, says online learning can put additional strain on immigrant and low-income families. "I feel for the students whose parents don't know English or don't really know how to help their students."

"It's no longer private"

NPR spoke with counselors across the country, from California to Georgia, Oklahoma to Ohio, and nearly all said they worry about even the best-case scenario — when they're able to connect with a student face-to-face using video chat technology. Their fear: privacy.

At school, "we have some sort of office space... where students can feel like they're having a private conversation with counselors," says Coleman in Chicago. "Now we're asking them to be vulnerable in some capacity at home. And for so many students, home is a space where they're triggered or they don't feel comfortable sharing ... because it's no longer private."

Yes, the student's bedroom door may be closed, says Ramirez in Redwood Valley, but "at any given point, someone can walk in or, you know, mom's down in the living room. She can probably hear [our] conversation." And that might keep students from really opening up about things like basic stress or even abuse.

The same holds true for many elementary school counselors.

"We do small group counseling for kids [who] are adjusting to a variety of changes, and there's an element of confidentiality that's built into that group," says Marie Weller, an elementary school counselor in Delaware, Ohio. "So I can't do a group online. I can't use Canvas or Zoom or Google Hangouts for a group because I can't get the confidentiality. So [I'm] trying to figure out, how can I check in?"

Getting creative

In Lawrenceville, Laura Ross admits: These have been trying times. But there's also a surprising upside, she says. The distance from students has forced her to get creative about how she uses technology to build a bridge back to them.

Before the outbreak, Ross helped create an after-school club for students who identify as LGBTQ+. When school closed, Ross set up a Google Classroom and asked if the club's members wanted to continue to meet virtually. "They definitely did. And the reactions were just a relief that they were still going to have the support of that club... the place that they could truly be themselves."

Ross says they even meet at the same time each week, just on Zoom.

On her last day in the office, before Ohio closed its schools, Marie Weller remembers starting to leave — then hesitating beside the childlike puppets she sometimes uses in her classroom counseling presentations. "Huh," she thought. "Maybe I'll be able to use these."

Weller and her fellow elementary school counselors say one important part of their job is making sure all students have the social-emotional skills and coping strategies they'll need to navigate a complex world. How can they do that now, from home?

Weller improvised.

She set up a smartphone camera in her house, surrounded by those puppets — a kind of surrogate classroom audience — and set about recording mini counseling lessons from her kitchen. Instead of the chime she normally uses to begin a lesson, she rings a mixing bowl with a red spatula. To teach kids about how and why they should filter what they say, leaving hurtful thoughts unspoken, she opens the coffee maker to show them how a real, paper filter works.

Weller does her own editing and even got permission from folk music favorites The Irish Rovers to use their song "What's Cooking In The Kitchen" as her opening theme. The resulting videos are brief, rich and charming, with lines like, "Your brain's amygdala acts like a guard dog."

And in Tulsa, Sarah Kirk is doing something similar, posting videos where she's sitting on the floor of her house, surrounded by colorful pennants and stuffed animals. Her dog, Crew, a cuddly 80-pound sheepadoodle (nearly as big as Kirk), even makes a camera-blocking cameo.

In her first episode, Kirk read a story meant to reassure children she can no longer hug. It's about how we all have an invisible string that connects us, even when we're far apart.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

Nearly all K-12 schools in the United States are now closed. We know this has been a tough transition for many teachers, but what about remote counselling? School counselors aren't just academic guides; often they're also mental health first responders and a trusted adult for kids, especially teenagers who need a sympathetic ear. As NPR's Cory Turner reports, this is hard to replicate with a laptop and a cellphone.

CORY TURNER, BYLINE: Imagine you're a high school counselor right now stuck at home. You're video chatting with a student who's in tears. Her senior year has just been canceled, and her parents aren't getting along. For counselor Franciene Sabens in Carbondale, Ill., this is not a hypothetical.

FRANCIENE SABENS: I mean, I want to hug them all, but I really wanted to hug that one.

TURNER: And that's not even the roughest part of the counselor's job right now. Before schools closed, Laura Ross, a counselor in Lawrenceville, Ga., says her eighth-graders were pretty easy to find.

LAURA ROSS: I mean, they just stopped by to say hello. They stopped by when they're upset just to come in and talk.

TURNER: But now Ross says connecting with students takes work.

ROSS: Through email, calling them, calling parents and checking in on students to see how they're doing.

TURNER: And remember - for lots of reasons, counselors don't just have students on speed dial. So Franciene Sabens says her go-to right now is...

SABENS: Email, email, email, email - lots of emails.

TURNER: But even that won't work for students who don't have email because they're 6 years old.

SARAH KIRK: You targeted exactly what keeps me up at night.

TURNER: Sarah Kirk is an elementary school counselor in Tulsa, Okla. She says she's making 20 to 40 phone calls a day, almost all of them to parents and caregivers, not kids. It's not just that she misses her students; she also worries that if a child's not OK at home and needs help, she won't know.

KIRK: It's hard on the school counselor's heart. That's for sure.

TURNER: This came up a lot with counselors of students of all ages. Brian Coleman is a high school counselor in Chicago, and he says - best case - when he can talk face-to-face with a student via video chat, he still might not get the truth.

BRIAN COLEMAN: And for so many students, home is a space where they're triggered or they don't feel comfortable.

EVELYN RAMIREZ: At any given point, someone can walk in.

TURNER: Evelyn Ramirez is a middle school counselor in rural Redwood Valley, Calif. And she says students aren't going to open up if the problem is sitting in the other room.

RAMIREZ: You know, Mom's down in the living room; she can probably hear my conversation. So that's something that students may face with not opening up about what's really bothering them, the stressor being at home.

TURNER: There are lots of other reasons counselors are worried, too. Parents are losing jobs. Many kids might not be getting enough food. In fact, I spoke with 10 counselors from all over the country - big city, rural, suburban - and most of them use the same word to describe what kids are going through right now.

KIRK: It's definitely a trauma.

COLEMAN: Trauma, even trauma...

SABENS: Traumatic experience of not having...

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: This is a collective trauma that we're experiencing.

TURNER: And so for now, counselors are doing everything they can. Before the outbreak, Laura Ross in Georgia was planning an empathy word wall next to the cafeteria. So now she's moved it online. And Sara Kirk in Tulsa has been posting videos to YouTube where she reads aloud to kids and even gets help with a singalong.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Singing) If you're happy and you know it, clap your hands. If you're happy and you know it, and you really want to show it, if you're happy...

TURNER: Cory Turner, NPR News.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Singing) If you're happy and you know it, stomp your feet. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.