How Making History Unmade A Family

May 16, 2019
Originally published on May 16, 2019 8:56 pm

Fifteen years ago Friday, Hillary and Julie Goodridge married amid great fanfare and great protests.

In pastel suits, with broad smiles and colorful streamers, they exchanged vows and rings just hours after Massachusetts became the first state in America to allow same-sex marriage.

The Goodridges were the face of the movement. The lawsuit that made gay and lesbian marriages a reality bears their name: Goodridge v. Department of Public Health. Historians often divide the equal-marriage movement into "before Goodridge" and "after Goodridge."

But less than five years later, they were getting divorced. In winning the right to marry, they lost their own marriage.

Now, Hillary, Julie and their daughter, Annie Goodridge, are speaking more candidly about the entirety of their experience.

"If you look at any interview that we've done, we've never talked about the trauma," says Julie Goodridge. "But I think that it's important to tell the full story."

The making of a family

Many years into their relationship but long before Hillary and Julie were involved in any court case, they were dreaming about having a child.

Because they were a lesbian couple, marriage was forbidden. But they wanted to do something to mark that they were a family. So, they say, they dug through their family trees and picked a common last name: Goodridge.

Julie remembers thinking, "Oh that sounds positive; let's pick that!"

Hillary and Julie Goodridge with their daughter, Annie (center). "It was a lot of stress for all of us, all the time," says Annie, now 23, of her parents' involvement in the lawsuit that made same-sex marriages legal. "When you have to be on all the time, it's hard to turn yourself off."
Meredith Nierman / WGBH

A few years later, their daughter made a dramatic appearance. She was rushed to the newborn intensive care unit, and Julie, her biological mother, was also in critical condition receiving intensive care. But Hillary was stuck in the hospital's waiting room. With no legal relationship to either of them, she was unable to visit or help make medical decisions.

"It's not like that happened and we thought, 'We have to sue for marriage equality,' " remembers Hillary. But later, that was one of the memories that motivated them to find a way to formalize their relationship, she says.

As the story goes, the immediate impetus was a simple question from 3-year-old Annie: "If you love each other, then why aren't you married?" By the time Annie was 5, they were the named plaintiffs in the lawsuit that would spur a decade of intense national debate.

The trauma of perfection

As the lawsuit gained momentum and the questions of same-sex marriage consumed the country, Hillary and Julie Goodridge say, the pressure mounted and the resistance grew. Now, with 15 years of distance, they say the trauma they experienced during that time took a few different forms.

Initially, Hillary says, they felt the pressure to be perfect.

It was "the stress of feeling like I have the entire community resting on our being likeable," she says. Every TV outlet wanted shots of Hillary flipping pancakes, Julie ironing, and Annie eating breakfast.

"We had to look like the girls who could be next door," says Hillary. "Not too threatening." No leather. No piercings. Just two moms and their curly-haired daughter.

"It was a lot of stress for all of us, all the time," says Annie, now 23. "When you have to be on all the time, it's hard to turn yourself off."

The trauma of being a target

The Goodridge lawsuit became a call to arms for opponents of same-sex marriage, including then-President George W. Bush. In his 2004 State of the Union address, just a few months after the decision came down, he declared to thunderous applause: "Our nation must defend the sanctity of marriage."

"I remember watching that and thinking, 'Oh my gosh. He's talking about us,' " Hillary says. "It really got crazy very quickly."

Across the country there were efforts to ban same-sex marriage. Forty-one states ultimately limited marriage to heterosexual couples.

In the middle of it all, Hillary got a voicemail from her mother that went something like this: "Hi, darling. Well, I see today you've managed to piss off the pope and the president. But when you get done with that, please give your mother a call."

The pope and the president were pissed off, and soon Annie's playmates were, too. Elementary school classmates refused to come to her house; she was called homophobic slurs; and opponents sent around a flyer.

"It went into our sex life and how we were harming our daughter," recalls Julie. "It was a mass mailing." And Annie remembers, "it was sent to the house of every family that was at my school."

Julie says walking into Annie's school, "we felt a little bit like animals being looked at that were in cages in a zoo."

Losing each other

After spending all day in the public eye, often discussing their relationship, the last thing they wanted to do when they got home was discuss their relationship.

"We kind of went our separate ways in the house," says Julie.

Annie echoes that sentiment: "When you have to be so public about every tiny detail of your lives, it really exacerbates any minute divide between how you deal with stress and what you need to do at the end of the day."

Hillary and Julie says seeking couples counseling wasn't an option. "We couldn't do that. It felt like too much of a risk. It felt like the word would get out," remembers Julie.

Less than two years after getting married, Hillary and Julie had separated. A few years later, they were divorced. When news of their split was leaked to the media, it sent shock waves through the gay community.

Julie remembers receiving "an incredibly nasty email about how we were going to be destroying the gay community. It went on for several pages. And I just felt like saying, 'This is not what I chose. I'm doing the best I can.' "

"I felt like our family let everyone down," says Annie, who was 10 when her parents separated.

Two smiling brides

The Supreme Court has now guaranteed same-sex couples the right to marry nationwide. Public opinion has shifted dramatically in support of gay and lesbian marriages. And the Goodridges have been able to step out of the limelight.

The three of them still spend Christmas together. They exchange Mother's Day gifts. When their dog was alive — affectionately named "Mary Bonauto" after their lawyer in the case — they all helped care for her.

And, in some fundamental ways, they still think of themselves a family. "Would I ever consider changing my name? The answer is no," says Julie.

In Julie's office, there's a picture from a gay-pride march. Somebody is holding a sign that said 'Brown Roe and Goodridge.'" Their state lawsuit was printed alongside monumental Supreme Court decisions. "I just kind of love that," Julie says.

When asked if it was worth it, they are quick to say it was heart-wrenching personally but, they think, good for the country and the world. It was worth it, they decide, but they're not sure they would do it all again.

Then, they tell a story: A few weeks ago, a waitress at a nearby restaurant showed them pictures of her wedding. Looking at the shots, they saw two smiling brides staring back.

"I remember thinking, 'She has absolutely no idea who we are.' And that's what was kind of great," says Julie. "She was just showing us because she could and she felt comfortable to bring her pictures to her place of work."

"Every single time that I scrolled through them, I would cry a little bit because you would see they're so happy and you feel like you had a part in that," says Annie.

After all, the Goodridges say, it is nice to have their family name stamped on something that made so many gay couples happy.

Copyright 2019 WGBH Radio. To see more, visit WGBH Radio.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Fifteen years ago this week, Massachusetts became the first state in America to allow same-sex marriages. That followed a court challenge led by Hillary and Julie Goodridge. The couple wed as soon as they could with great fanfare and protest.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: Till death do we part.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: Till death do we part.

SHAPIRO: They divorced less than five years later. The Goodridges say in winning the right to marry, they lost their own marriage. They've been reluctant to talk about the personal toll of that landmark court battle until now. Gabrielle Emanuel of member station WGBH has their story.

GABRIELLE EMANUEL, BYLINE: Historians often divide the equal-marriage movement into "before Goodridge" and "after Goodridge." A decade later, the Supreme Court weighed in, guaranteeing same-sex couples the right to marry nationwide. Still today, the Goodridge decision is held up alongside monumental Supreme Court decisions. Julie has a picture...

JULIE GOODRIDGE: From a gay pride march - and somebody was holding a sign that said Brown, Roe and Goodridge. And you know, I just kind of love that.

EMANUEL: But, Julie says, it's not all puppies and kittens. Fifteen years after their wedding, the Goodridges have decided to speak more candidly about the entirety of their experience. Hillary and Julie and their daughter Annie Goodridge came together at Julie's apartment in Boston.

J. GOODRIDGE: Every time - if you look at any interview that we've done, we've never talked about the trauma.

EMANUEL: Julie says the trauma took a couple different forms. Initially, Hillary remembers, it was the pressure to be perfect.

HILLARY GOODRIDGE: The stress of feeling like I have the entire community resting on our being likable.

EMANUEL: Hillary says every TV outlet wanted shots of her flipping pancakes, Julie ironing, Annie eating breakfast.

H. GOODRIDGE: We had to, you know, sort of look like the girls who could be next door, be not too threatening. You know, Julie and I weren't walking around in leather.

EMANUEL: No leather, no piercings - just two moms and their curly-haired daughter. They say the trauma also came from being targeted. The Goodridge lawsuit became a call to arms for opponents of same-sex marriage, including then-President George W. Bush.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

GEORGE W BUSH: Our nation must defend the sanctity of marriage.

(APPLAUSE)

H. GOODRIDGE: I remember watching that and thinking - oh, my gosh.

J. GOODRIDGE: Well, we were, like - we just looked at each other. We were watching the State of the Union.

H. GOODRIDGE: He's talking about us.

J. GOODRIDGE: Yeah.

H. GOODRIDGE: It really got crazy very quickly.

EMANUEL: Across the country, there were efforts to forbid same-sex marriage. Forty-one states ultimately limited marriage to heterosexual couples. In the middle of it all, Hillary remembers getting a voicemail from her mother that went something like this.

H. GOODRIDGE: Hi, darling. Well, I see today you've managed to piss off the pope and the president. But when you get done with that, please give your mother a call.

EMANUEL: The pope and the president and soon Annie's playmates, too. Elementary school classmates refused to come to her house. She was called homophobic slurs. And Julie and Annie recall opponents sent around a flyer.

J. GOODRIDGE: It went into, you know, our sex life and how we were harming our daughter.

ANNIE GOODRIDGE: It was sent to the house of every family that was at my school.

EMANUEL: And the final type of trauma, Julie says, was losing each other.

J. GOODRIDGE: You know, we would kind of go our separate ways in the house.

EMANUEL: Julie says seeking couples counseling wasn't an option.

J. GOODRIDGE: We couldn't do that. It felt like too much of a risk. It felt like the word would get out.

EMANUEL: Less than two years after getting married, Hillary and Julie had separated. When news got out, it sent shockwaves through the gay community. Julie remembers getting...

J. GOODRIDGE: An incredibly nasty email about how we were going to be destroying the gay community. And I just felt like saying - you know what? - this is not what I chose. You know, I'm doing the best I can.

EMANUEL: Annie was 10 when they separated.

A. GOODRIDGE: It felt like our family let everyone down.

EMANUEL: With 15 years of distance, the three still spend Christmas together. And they say it was worth it, but they're not sure if they'd do it all again. Then, Annie starts a story. Nearby, there's a restaurant.

A. GOODRIDGE: And there's this waiters who works there.

EMANUEL: A few weeks ago, the waitress showed them pictures of her wedding. Julie says they saw two smiling brides.

J. GOODRIDGE: I remember thinking, she has absolutely no idea who we are. And it - that's what was kind of...

H. GOODRIDGE: It was kind of awesome.

J. GOODRIDGE: That's what was kind of great...

H. GOODRIDGE: That was great.

J. GOODRIDGE: ...About looking at those pictures, is she was just showing us because she could. And she felt comfortable to bring her pictures to her place of work.

A. GOODRIDGE: They were beautiful pictures.

J. GOODRIDGE: And, Annie Goodrich says, it's nice to have their family name stamped on something that made many gay couples happy.

For NPR News, I'm Gabrielle Emanuel in Boston.

(SOUNDBITE OF BIBIO SONG, "A TOUT A L'HEURE") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.